Each of these was a going concern with a website, a support desk and customers who believed their balance was real. Some were robbed, some ran out of money, and some spent the deposits. The common thread is that the customers did not hold their own keys, so when the company stopped existing, so did their coins.
Failures where customer funds were at stake, plotted by the date the trouble became public and the value at stake at the time. Figures are the widely reported ones and are approximate — in a bankruptcy the true number often takes years to settle, and the headline figure and the final shortfall are rarely the same. Hover any point for what happened and whether customers were made whole. The three buttons re-measure the same events: what the money was worth on the day, the same sum expressed in bitcoin, and what that bitcoin would be worth at today’s price, which is fetched live. The list of events is hand-kept and added to as they warrant; the prices around it are not. One entry is not an exchange at all: the Liquid sidechain, where the bitcoin backing every L-BTC is held by a federation of fifteen institutions rather than by the people holding the L-BTC. It is here for the same reason as the rest — somebody else had the keys.
The small ones. Dozens of lesser exchanges have closed quietly with customer balances inside, and those rarely make the news at all. It also leaves out losses that were not custodial — protocol exploits, bridge hacks and token collapses — because the point here is narrower: what happens when somebody else holds your keys. Several firms on this list did repay in full, which is worth saying; the risk is not that it always ends badly, but that you cannot know in advance. One caution on the bitcoin figures: where an exchange lost actual coins the number is the coins. Where the loss was dollars or another currency — most of the bankruptcies, and Coincheck, which lost NEM — it is that sum converted at the bitcoin price on the day, which is a way of comparing sizes rather than a claim about what was in the wallets. The tooltip says which is which.